Calm blue-green lagoon water in front of closely spaced, updated two-story homes and neatly planted waterfront gardens in Foster City.

Reading Foster City's Price Per Square Foot Against Its Neighbors

In November 1971, the Kay Homes sales office on what is now Leo Drive listed new Foster City houses from $39,990 to $45,990, plus options. The model homes sat on a cul-de-sac off Hillsdale Boulevard. The street was later closed off from Hillsdale, which is why Leo Drive and Saturn Court still have an odd shape. The Foster City Historical Society keeps the brochure, scanned from one original buyer's family files. Foster City was planned and sold as a whole town, so its houses and lots came out of one plan. That plan still shapes the town's price per square foot today.

Foster City sells for less per square foot than the cities around it. Its houses are not smaller. The lots under them are.

The per-foot gap, read for a full year

The cleanest comparison is the 2025 annual single-family report from SAMCAR, which uses MLSListings data. For calendar year 2025, Foster City's median was $1,130 per square foot across 103 sales. The neighbors were all higher over the same year:

  • Redwood City: $1,225
  • San Mateo: $1,235
  • Belmont: $1,244
  • San Carlos: $1,415

Most people would guess Foster City's houses are smaller. They are not. In the same 2025 report, the average Foster City house measured 2,042 square feet. That is about the same as San Carlos at 2,063, Belmont at 2,079 and Redwood City at 2,010, and larger than San Mateo at 1,861.

So a Foster City buyer in 2025 got a house about the size of a San Carlos house for $285 less per foot, by our arithmetic. Across 2,000 square feet, that comes to roughly $570,000. The medians show the same thing: $2,200,000 in Foster City against $2,650,000 in San Carlos for 2025.

Where the gap lines up

The column that tracks the per-foot gap is average lot size. Foster City's 2025 average lot was 6,038 square feet. San Mateo's was 7,032, San Carlos's 7,671, Redwood City's 7,985 and Belmont's 8,487. A Foster City house came with about 1,600 fewer square feet of land than a San Carlos house and about 2,400 fewer than a Belmont house.

SAMCAR's report lists price per square foot next to average home size, and the sale price behind it covers house and land together. When two cities have houses of the same size but different lot sizes, the per-foot figure mostly measures the land. Read that way, Foster City's discount is a price on land, not a markdown on the house. The report can't separate land from location, condition and every other factor. Still, the house sizes match and the lots don't, and that pattern points one way.

The lots come from the way the town was built. Former Public Works Director Richard Hopper described it in a talk the Foster City Historical Society has published. Brewer's Island covered about 3,000 acres, and T. Jack Foster's organization bought most of it for a little under $12 million. A 300-acre tract in the northwest stayed out of the sale and later became Mariners Island in San Mateo. The land was raised with hydraulic sand fill dredged from San Bruno Shoal, around the clock, seven days a week, for six years. The lagoon's shape came from an engineering limit: land could drain properly only within about 1,100 feet of it. The streets, islands and lots were planned at once, on manufactured land, and the master plan is "pretty much very close to the way it is today," Hopper said.

Why the median misleads in Foster City, and price per foot doesn't

Because the town was built from one plan, price per foot is a steadier gauge inside Foster City than the median. The October numbers show it.

SAMCAR's October 2026 single-family report puts Foster City's median sale price at $2,702,500 across six sales, at 107 percent of list price and an average of 22 days on market. In October 2025, the median was $1,965,000 across 11 sales. Taken at face value, that is a 37.5 percent jump in a year.

Price per foot tells a different story for the same two months: $1,095 in October 2025 and $1,112 in October 2026. That is a $17 rise. Most of the median's jump came from which houses sold. October 2026's six sales averaged 2,398 square feet on 7,361-square-foot lots. October 2025's eleven averaged 1,973 square feet on 5,426-square-foot lots. With so few sales, a few larger houses on larger lots can move the median by hundreds of thousands of dollars without the market changing much.

January through October 2026 show the same pattern. Over those months, Foster City's monthly single-family median ranged from $2,050,000 in August to $2,741,944 in February. Over the same ten months, the per-foot figure stayed between $1,045 in April and $1,195 in January. In a city with roughly two to eleven house sales a month, the per-foot figure is the one to watch.

The per-foot gap with the neighbors held through most of the year. From February through October 2026, Foster City had the lowest median price per square foot of the five cities compared here in every month. The one exception was January, when Redwood City came in at $1,058 against Foster City's $1,195. In October 2026, Foster City's $1,112 compared with $1,224 in Belmont, $1,356 in San Mateo, $1,413 in Redwood City and $1,507 in San Carlos.

Supply is thin as well. Foster City ended October 2026 with five single-family homes in inventory, which SAMCAR counts as 0.7 months of supply. The lower per-foot price has not meant a slow market. Houses are selling over list. They cost less per foot because each sale includes less land.

Where there's no lot, the discount disappears

If the gap is about land, it should shrink where buyers aren't buying a lot. Condos and townhomes, which SAMCAR groups as common-interest developments, are the test. In October 2026, Foster City's common-interest units sold at a median of $845 per square foot on four sales. That was above San Mateo at $775 and Redwood City at $724. The median unit sold for $1,312,500. This is one month on a handful of sales, and the order shifts. In September, Foster City's $796 trailed San Carlos at $933 and Belmont at $990. Still, the steady single-family discount doesn't show up on the attached side.

Some of this goes back to the plan too. Neighborhood 5, built in the 1970s and out of numerical order, was made up entirely of condominium and cluster developments, among them The Islands and Lido Island. Foster City's attached homes were part of the original design. Our earlier guide to buying a condo or townhome in Foster City covers that side of the market.

What the citywide figure doesn't separate

A citywide figure treats every Foster City lot the same, and inside the town they are not the same. Hopper described the seven original islands, built with concrete T-walls along their "narrow water" edges, and noted that "real estate agents know this today, there's narrow water and wide water." The first house was the Captain's House on Shooting Star Isle, Jack Foster's own home. An aerial photo from 1964 shows Neighborhoods 1, 2 and 3 already underway.

Lagoon frontage, wide water versus narrow water and the condition of a house built in the 1960s or 1970s all affect what a particular Foster City home sells for. SAMCAR's monthly reports don't break any of them out. Our earlier comparison of lagoon-front and neighborhood living in Foster City covers the everyday differences. For pricing, the useful benchmark is recent sales of similar homes on similar water, not the citywide median.

Questions buyers ask about this comparison

Does a lower price per square foot mean Foster City is the better value? It means the same budget buys about the same size house with less land under it. In 2025, a Foster City house averaged 2,042 square feet on a 6,038-square-foot lot, against 2,079 square feet on 8,487 in Belmont. Which matters more to you, interior space or yard, decides whether that is a good trade.

Why did Foster City's median jump so much this fall? Mostly because of which houses sold. The six October 2026 sales averaged 2,398 square feet, and the per-foot figure rose only $17 from October 2025.

Which month's numbers should I trust? Use a full year when you can. In a city with single-digit monthly sales, the 2025 annual report shows the pattern more clearly than any single month. For current conditions, read the latest month's per-foot figure alongside it.

The citywide per-foot figure is a starting point, and lot, water and condition are what set a single home's price. If you're weighing Foster City against Belmont, San Carlos or San Mateo, or want to see what your own Foster City home would sell for at today's per-foot prices, Lana Morin Pierce can go through recent comparable sales with you. You can start with a home valuation or Book a Consultation, and see more about the city on the Foster City neighborhood page.

Work With Us

Etiam non quam lacus suspendisse faucibus interdum. Orci ac auctor augue mauris augue neque. Bibendum at varius vel pharetra. Viverra orci sagittis eu volutpat. Platea dictumst vestibulum rhoncus est pellentesque elit ullamcorper.

Follow Me on Instagram